Jul 18 2022

Mystery Friday Foto #29 Partially Solved: A Mitchell at the “Proposed Entrance to the Motor Parkway at Hicksville”


My favorite co-author Al Velocci needed your help to solve this weekend's Mystery Foto.

Answers to the Mystery Foto questions

Identify

  • The location of the Mystery Foto and orientation of the photographer. Provide a rationale. Note: Both Al and I have no idea!

Some good guesses below. However, there is nothing conclusive. It is possible the caption to the postcard was wrong.

  • The make, model and year of the automobile

1909-1911 Mitchell

  • What type of store was owned by the publisher H.F. Huettner? What was Huettner's first name? Where was he born?

Henry F. Huettner (1854-1930), born in Lower Saxony, Germany, owned a general store at the corner of Marie Street and Broadway in Hicksville. The store is still standing today.

Comments (10)

Congrats to Greg O., Art Kleiner, Steve Lucas and Brian McCarthy for identifying the Mitchell.

Kudos  to David Miller, Art Kleiner, Brian McCarthy and Steve Lucas for providing information and jpegs on Henry Huettner.

Enjoy,

Howard Kroplick



Close-Ups



Comments

Jul 15 2022 Greg O. 1:36 PM

Solving the easiest question is the car. It looks to be a 1904/5ish Mitchell. Mitchells used many styles of radiators, but this one matches the early cars like this 1904 runabout.

Location is a bit more difficult. Search continues…

image
Jul 15 2022 John Cunningham 2:19 PM

I have no idea about the car so I won’t embarrass myself with trying but HF Huettner is from Germany and owned a department store on W. Marie st in Hicksville.  I believe his first name was Henry.  As far as the location of the picture, I’m gonna guess somewhere on Division Ave in Hicksville.  That road seems broken up between Hicksville and Levittown and I can assume it was once a connected road that leads straight to the Motor Parkway.  Again, just a guess and I have nothing to back up any of it.

Jul 16 2022 David Miller 11:57 AM

Where could there even be an entrance to the Motor Parkway from Hicksville?  The race routes of the Vanderbilt Cups were only temporary routes that went into Hicksville territory and weren’t actually parts of the Motor Parkway.  Otherwise, the closest most logical points of entry to the parkway nearest to Hicksville would either be Jerusalem ave or Newbridge rd.  Going by the picture I’m going to say that the vehicle is in front of the Newbridge hotel which is very close to the parkway.  There was also the “borrow pit” area near here on the south side of the parkway west of Newbridge rd opposite the hotel.  This would seemingly be a big enough area to construct an additional toll lodge for access to the parkway.  The car in question in the photo is a 1909 “Mitchell”.  H.F. Huettner, (first name Henry) owned a furniture store on the northeast corner of Marie st and Broadway.  It later became Whelan drugs.  I think he was born in Germany.

Jul 17 2022 Art Kleiner 7:09 AM

Nice postcard. 

I would assume the proposed entrance would be near the southern part of Hicksville near Orchard Road where the Motor Parkway ran.

Auto might be a 1909 Mitchell “30”.

Henry F. Huettner owned a prominent dept. store in Hicksville on the corner of E. Marie and Broadway from 1876 through the 1930s.  It sold a wide range of goods including furniture, rugs, food, millinery items and pianos.  Huettner was also involved in civic projects including an early Rolsyn power station and the Hicksville to Mineola Trolley (1909).  As written in his great grandson Charles’
autobiography Henry was born in Germany (Region Hannover, Lower Saxony (Niedersachsen) and supplied furnishings to the north shore estate owners, including Vanderbilt. 


image image image
Jul 17 2022 Art Kleiner 7:11 AM

Additional photos of the Huettner dept. store.

image image image
Jul 17 2022 Brian D McCarthy 6:44 PM

Hard to make out the wording on the grille, but I think it’s - National - an early automobile manufacturer. Think this image may have been taken near the north turn from the LIMP then onto Hicksville Rd. Turn was created for 1909 & 10 VCR. So maybe that describes the proposed entrance to motor pkwy?

Henry Frederick Huettner, born in Germany. 1900 census describes him & family owning a - Dry Goods/Grocery - at the southeast corner of Broadway & Old Country Rd. There’s a 7/11 there now, previously a Taco Bell. Below is the 1900 census, a 1914 map showing his property, a - Printing Office Hicksville Press - next door, and his place of rest. Courtesy of Wikipedia, Ancestry, Historic Map Works. : )

image image image
Jul 17 2022 Steve Lucas 8:51 PM

Assuming the Hicksville reference is correct, the photo (or sketch) was probably along the LIMP somewhere between Wantagh Avenue and Newbridge Road. The car looks like a 1911 Mitchell Touring. Henry F. Huettner was born in Hanover, Lower Saxony, Germany in 1854 and died in 1930. He is buried in Plain Lawn Cemetery in Hicksville. At one time, he owned a building on the corner of Broadway and Marie Street in Hicksville. It’s getting late and that’s all I’ve got.

Jul 17 2022 Chris Lindsley 8:55 PM

I can try to answer the first question. Those entrance would have been E of Bloomingdale Rd but W of Deadmans Curve.  I would place it around between today’s Rte 107 and Stewart Ave

Jul 17 2022 Brian D McCarthy 9:10 PM

I originally thought the auto was a National. I’m now pretty certain it’s a Mitchell Automobile. Don’t know the year, but likely no later than 1910.

Jul 18 2022 frank femenias 3:00 PM

Dunno but two possibilities:
Motor Parkway at Newbridge Rd near the Newbridge Rd hotel looking West.
Motor Parkway at Jerusalem Av near Polaris Ballfield, looking South.
It appears the auto just exited the Motor Parkway from a fork offering an east-west option. Note the walkway from the house leading to a street or driveway.

image image image
Jul 19 2022 al velocci 9:49 AM

Howard, My son suggested that we check to see any of the Parkway’s officers and those on the Board of Directors had a connection to Hicksville. Didn’t find any. Decided to see if any of the stockholders did. Found one. A Mrs. Johanna Taliafero. She was one of only two women who purchased Motor Parkway stock. (Willie K’s mother, Alva Belmont, was the other.) Mrs. Taliaferro owned quite a bit of property in the Hickville area, and it appears that she lived on Jerusalem Ave. near Marie Street. I would like to think that it is her in the auto leaving her estate. I think that she knew Huttner well as one of her propertied abut his store.

Jul 24 2022 Mark D 10:30 PM

Hers a link to a wonderful map of Hicksville

https://www.loc.gov/item/75694782/

Jul 26 2022 Brian D McCarthy 6:45 PM

Nice find, Mark D : )  The panorama maps are very detailed with building numbers and directory.

Leave a Comment