Mar 08 2022

Greg O’s Garage: The Great Wall of East Hills and Long Island Motor Parkway director Clarence Mackay


A recently re-discovered driveway remnants of Clarence Mackay's Harbor Hill has finally been documented.

 

Greg O.

Clarence Hungerford Mackay's Harbor Hill Estate once stood at the highest point in Nassau County in Roslyn (now East Hills.)

Clarence Mackay (1874-1938) was the heir to the Comstock silver fortune and was a major figure in the development of the international telegraph business.

Mackay  can be seen here to Willie K.'s left during a speech at the Start/Finish line of the 1906 Vanderbilt Cup Races.

As listed in the 1906 prospectus, Clarence Mackay was an original director/incorporator of the Long Island Motor Parkway.

A recent re-discovery by the Roslyn Landmark Society has uncovered a long, 300-foot-long section of his 1-mile front drive to the front of Harbor Hill buried behind the homes on Mimosa and Ash Drives. Exciting, as this particular section has gone unnoticed except by residents for decades.

In this image, the drive was on top of the wall.

The 1-mile long south drive extended from the Mackay Estate Gate Lodge at Harbor Hill Road and Roslyn Road (currently being restored) and wound its way up the second largest hill on Long Island to the front of the mansion.

The re-discovered section can be seen on historic Google Earth imagery from 2016 and includes inner and outer retaining walls never before recognized.

Graphically overlaid on top of a current satellite view (courtesy of Frank Femenias) one can see that the main drive followed current Mimosa Dr. for about 1500 feet before turning 180 degrees to wind up the hillside.

The drive seen here believed to be along Mimosa Dr. shortly after completion. The ivy-covered outer retaining wall on the right.

The 16-foot-wide drive with stone gutters and beautiful landscaping built along with the mansion between 1900-1902 cost roughly $150,000 alone (about 5 million today).

Some famous visitors to Harbor Hill such as Charles Lindbergh after his Trans-Atlantic triumph in 1927, The Prince of Wales and even Cardinal Eugenio Pacelli, the future the Pope Pius XII, have been on this drive.

As stated by Al Velocci in a previous post on the Roslyn Landmark Society website, to construct the mansion and its incredible drive, about 166,000 tons of granite*, at a cost of $117,006.76*, was purchased from the 4-acre demolition site of the 1840's Murray Hill reservoir at 5th Ave & 42nd St in 1898. The reservoir seen in this photo from the 1870's.

*Source: Richard Guy Wilson's book, 'Harbor Hill Portrait of a House'.

On the site of the former Murray Hill/Croton Reservoir now sits the New York City Public Library.

In the lower section of the library, the original foundation of the former reservoir can still be seen.

With the explicit permission of the kind and curious residents along Mimosa and Ash Drives, members of the Roslyn Landmark Society were allowed on their private property to document this long-forgotten stretch of driveway.

In this image, the drive was in front of the wall, excavated to make room for the house,

Longer view. The drive again was in front of  the wall, partially excavated in the early 1960s for the backyard.

The top of the hill where it turned inward and over Ash Drive. Heavier stone can be seen at the bottom for support and base of the drive, and lighter stone used on the upper portion creating the guardrail of sorts seen in the previous photo after completion. In this image, the drive was behind the wall.

Standing on the actual drive towards the top looking at the outer retaining wall. The drive in this view was to the right of the wall. 

A different  section of the wall behind a house or as the resident (recently from Israel) likes to call it, her 'Wailing Wall'. The drive was on top of this section of the wall.

This particular small section was previously documented and photographed by Roslyn historian Roy Moger in 1963.

This same granite was used all over the estate. Here, the still existing Harbor Hill Water Tower is built in the same fashion and stone as the drive.

The most surprising discovery was the unknown presence of not one, but two walls consisting of an outer and inner retaining wall for the drive seen here.

The drive was located between these two arrows.

Both walls clearly seen here as the drive continues up the hillside. Residents were thrilled to finally know the history of the double walls that loomed in their backyard for decades. The property that the entire wall sits is all private and please do not trespass to view it. A utility pole marks the middle of the drive surrounded by walls on both sides.

Thanks to all the East Hills' residents who allowed the Roslyn Landmark Society to  document this forgotten piece of history.



Comments

Mar 08 2022 Brian D McCarthy 8:45 PM

Looks like you all had a full & fun day, the elevation in and around is steep.

Mar 09 2022 Art Kleiner 6:20 AM

Great job, Greg.

Mar 09 2022 Greg O. 8:00 AM

Thanks Art!

And yes Brian. Between the elevation and overgrowth, it’s very difficult to access most of the driveway. Getting permissions from residents also took a few days.

Mar 09 2022 Mike Cain 9:52 AM

That’s a great find Greg! Must have been fun to explore.

Mar 09 2022 Bill McLaughlin 1:51 PM

Great job. Did not know this was still here. If interested, I authored a very detailed website on Clarence Mackay. Unfortunately I have lost the ability to update it and some links are broken. But it still is full of lots of good info and pictures. Website: Mackayhistory.com
(Tap small blank box on upper right corner of each page to move to next page or tap section names on first page to navigate)
Bill McLaughlin

Mar 09 2022 Joe Oesterle 7:05 PM

Amazing post !!!  Thank you.

Mar 14 2022 Brian D McCarthy 6:23 PM

Below is a screenshot of the Estate in 1926. On the Nassau County LRV website, a neat little trick I stumbled on. Click on a current road in a neighborhood, then a street pattern will appear. Similar to the map above.

image
Mar 16 2022 Greg O. 6:51 PM

Thanks for the map Brian! And thanks to your map and a tip from one of Howard’s friends, we were able to locate other unknown retaining walls behind a private house in the neighborhood by what was the dog kennels.

image
Mar 16 2022 Brian D McCarthy 11:03 PM

No problem, Greg. Land Record Viewer Maps are a great tool.

Leave a Comment